Ahh, caramel…how the heck do you make a low-carb version of a PURE SUGAR product?! Allulose is the key for this recipe. It’s one of the few low-carb sweeteners that actually browns and caramelizes – because it is derived from sugar! It’s just as easy to make caramel sauce or chews with allulose compared to using sugar. No aftertaste, and no stomach troubles, and no blood sugar spikes.
A runnier caramel sauce used to decorate this plate.
A chewier caramel filling used for these sandwich cookies. Using less cream makes it firmer.
Ingredients
- 1 cup allulose rare sugar
- 1/2 cup water
- 1/4 cup heavy cream for chews; 1/2 cup heavy cream for sauce
- 2 Tbsp unsalted butter
- 1 Tbsp vanilla paste
- 1/2 tsp salt
Instructions
- Sprinkle a layer of allulose in a saucepan and place on med-high heat. Add water and swirl to dissolve.
- As the allulose heats up and dissolves, continue adding allulose in stages. Use a wet brush to push down anything sticking to the sides of the saucepan. Do not stir, as there is risk of crystallization.
- Monitor allulose continuously and cook until it reaches a desired caramel color. Don't let it burn! Remove from heat and stir in cream, keeping safe distance. It will get very bubbly.
- After cream is incorporated, add remaining ingredients and allow mixture to cool.
- For sauce: store in a jar and enjoy! Refrigeration will firm it up, but you can reheat if desired.
- For chews: pour into parchment-lined pan, fully cool, and cut into pieces.
What brand of Allulose do you like?
Hi there, I have only worked with the Keystone Pantry version made by Lang’s Chocolates. I am interested in trying other brands, but this one had the best price.
Hello, your recipes look amazing! And almost too beautiful to eat! I do (selfishly) wish you posted recipes more often!
I also have worked extensively with allulose and one thing you might want to mention in your recipe is that it caramelizes MUCH faster than sugar and that with allulose, if making caramel, as soon as it BEGINS to change color you should take it off the heat and add your cream. If you wait until it reaches the deep amber color you normally would with sugar, it will taste burnt.
Also I absolutely agree that it makes better caramel than erythritol (too much crystallization when it cools) or any other low carb sugar replacement!
Wish I had read this first! The caramel was a beautiful color and inedible it tasted so burnt! It went to the trash😪
Argh so sorry that happened! Wish I could give you my leftover sauce, I can’t eat it all!
Great advice—what color am I looking for?
You used the powdered; I have liquid. I wonder how much water (or none) to add using liquid version.
I don’t think you need to add any water. Nowadays I don’t add water when making caramel, I just add the cream and butter until I reach the desired consistency.
Thank you so much! I will try it tomorrow! You didn’t change anything else in your instructions when you started using the liquid?
Since the sugar is already incorporated into the liquid, once it started simmering, the color change happened very quickly. In fact, as I pulled it off the burner to add the cream, it got even darker. Once all the ingredients were incorporated, I wanted a sweeter taste. I added a little bit more salt, my favorite monk fruit and erythritol sweetener to taste, and stirred while everything was still hot. It came out great! Yum!
That’s great! Thanks so much for sharing your results!